Workers Online
Workers Online
Workers Online
  Issue No 83 Official Organ of LaborNet 09 February 2001  




.  LaborNET

.  Ask Neale

.  Tool of the Week


Jim Maher: The Politics of Wendell

So, big Wendell's jumped the fence, and the rugby worlds are buzzing with talk of the implications.


Anyone who watched the recent World Club Challenge between Brisbane and St Helens, when Sailor contrived to completely miss the tackle which led to Chris Joynt's score-equalling try, might have thought the bloke was already playing union. That, however, is hardly the issue.

Columnists and spokespersons from both sides of the increasingly blurred rugby border are putting their own spins on Sailor's voyage.

The simple fact is that union, for the first time in the best part of 100 years, is comprehensively out-gunning its competitor everywhere, with the exception, so far, of Papua New Guinea.

The reasons, however, are not those generally put forward by advocates of the 15-man strain. More than reflecting that game's inherent superiority, or some form of justice after decades of pillage, they have to do with propitious timeing and more than a little splashing about within league's teepee.

When Brisbane stockbroker/entrepreneur Paul "Porky" Morgan crossed over to the other side recently he was hailed by no less an authority on the matter than John Ribot as the architect of Super League.

While there might be some suspicion that Ribot grasped the occassion to engage in a spot of Pontius Pilateing if, in fact, his assessment was accurate then it should, in future, be said that league was "porkied".

What happened to Rugby League was a classic example of the fatal flaw in new-right philosophy - the view which holds that markets are sacrosanct, independent, self-regulating arbiters of the next step in economic Darwinism.

In fact, as multi-billionaire currency speculator George Souris points out, markets are prone to every prejudice, whim and cultural attachment of their players.

When Ribot, Morgan and co kicked off Super League they did so on the conviction that, having the superior product, league would retain and gain market share.

Their ideology precluded them from taking into account the glaringly, obvious human factor that everywhere the two games were played, with the possible exceptions of Queensland and NSW, union was the game of choice for the wealthy and well-connected.

This was a serious miscalculation.

Peter Fitzsimmons gloats over Sailor's passage in the SMH, arguing, understandably, that big-money league has been allowed its wicked way, snatching and sullying pure amateurs for far too long.

League, however, in its pre-Ribot incarnation was not a professional outfit in the modern, market-rules, understanding of the term. Its payments started from the premise of allowing ordinary people to compete in the face of a union establishment that effectively blocked those without independent means from progressing through its ranks.

Certainly, that changed through the 80's and 90's, but even when Ribot began to wreak his havoc most first graders still worked for their livings. League, in fact, was a peculiarly Australian form of professionalism, built on the back of poker machines in non-profit clubs. Restrictions, agreed between clubs, prevented market forces ratcheting player earnings unrecognisably above those of their fan base, whilst still allowing them to derive significant material benefits from their talents.

Union, on the other hand, far from a bastion of amateur purity, was riddled with under-counter payments and deceit.

That it chose to rectify this state of affairs at precisely the same time as league was "porkying" itself was, from its point of view, a most wonderful coincidence.

Through little more than accidents of history, Australian union went into the head-to-head commercial battle needing to sustain just three Super 12 teams, playing infrequently, in the build-up to an extended international programme, tailor-made for trans-national broadcasting.

Its opponent, on the other hand, is trying to sustain a 14-franchise competition, playing every single weekend from early February until late September on the way to an international series that nobody, least of all international television, gives a flying footy about. It is no wonder that News Ltd wants to prune the NRL premiership back to clubs still.

Worse still, Morgan, Ribot and their fellow-travellers deliberately and with malice of for-thought tore apart the bonds that tied clubs, players and fans together in a common culture.

Once, it was quite conceivable that men in Sailor's position, would have pursued their code because they were leaguies. No longer, each is now a businessmen, looking after number one - Ribot and his allies convinced them of that.

It is generally accepted that league, at the moment, produces the superior athlete and more scientifically analyses its game. That's why its technical coaches are being grabbed by union across the world, even in New Zealand where Warriors failure Mark Graham has been snapped up by Auckland's Super 12 franchise.

But so what?

More players of Sailor's status will make the journey to union because product superiority, even when tacitly admitted, does not neccessarily equate to market share.

For the long-term interests of their game Ribot and his cronies might have been better listening to JK Galbraith than Bobby Fulton but it's a bit late now - that particular ship has sailed.


*   View entire issue - print all of the articles!

*   Issue 83 contents

In this issue
*  Interview: Dispatch from Davos
ACTU President Shahran Burrow reports back on the trade union movement’s presence at last week’s meeting of the heavyweights of global capital.
*  Unions: After the Gold Rush
Recent mass sackings at high-profile e-businesses are beginning to expose the flimsiness of the ‘jobs for all’ predictions made on behalf of the sector.
*  Economics: The Other Davos
While the world’s business leaders met in Davos, a very different gathering was taking place in Porto Alegre, Brazil. Pat Ranald was there.
*  Politics: While We Were Snoozing
As we lay in our banana chair through summer the political world kept turning with a new man in the White House. Here’s what we missed while we were off the air.
*  History: Federation Day, 1901
One hundred years after Australia became a nation, Ralph Sawyer relives the original Federation Day through the eyes of Billy Hughes.
*  International: Burma: The Struggle Continues
As the internatinal community moves to bring Burma to account, APHEDA - Union Aid Abroad is working on the ground.
*  Review: Inside the Journopolis
In his new book, Rob Johnson brings the infamous Cash for Comment Affair to life.
*  Satire: Families Demand Longer Work Hours
A new report confirms the long held suspicion that employees who reduce their workload to spend more time with their spouse and children just end up annoying their families even more.

»  Union Busters Target Call Centres
»  Workers Take Message to World Bank
»  Korean Worker Bashed for Questioning Wages
»  Steelworkers Draw The Line
»  Sartor Thanks Workers for Games by Outsourcing Jobs
»  Outworkers Still Waiting for Action of Sweatshops
»  Workers Casualties in Wentworth Fire Sale
»  Fantastic Win for Furniture Workers
»  Billions Spent on Mine Takeovers
»  No Guarantees on Orange Jobs
»  M5 Project- Worker Pays the Price
»  Forum: Organising Youth in a Hostile Workplace
»  Western Sahara Marks 25 Years of Waiting
»  Action as Australia Considers WTO Ties

»  The Soapbox
»  Sport
»  Trades Hall
»  Tool Shed

Letters to the editor
»  Cavalier Attitude to Cricketers
»  Unions and the WEF: How should unions bridge the divide?
»  Botsman's Ivory Tower
»  Volunteering a Modest Proposal
»  Well Done, Workers Online

What you can do

Notice Board
- Check out the latest events

Latest Issue

View entire latest issue
- print all of the articles!

Previous Issues

Subject index

Search all issues

Enter keyword(s):

Workers Online - 2nd place Labourstart website of the year


Wobbly Radio

[ Home ][ Notice Board ][ Search ][ Previous Issues ][ Latest Issue ]

© 1999-2000 Labor Council of NSW

LaborNET is a resource for the labour movement provided by the Labor Council of NSW

Last Modified: 15 Nov 2005

[ Privacy Statement | Disclaimer | Credits ]

LaborNET is proudly created, designed and programmed by Social Change Online for the Labor Council of NSW


 Labor Council of NSW

[Workers Online]

[Social Change Online]