The Official Organ of LaborNET
click here to view the latest edition of Workers Online
The Official Organ of LaborNET
Free home delivery
Issue No. 220 14 May 2004  

Motherhood Statements
There is a term for political statements that are so bland they have lost their meaning � terms that no one could disagree with, designed to win the support of all people at all times.


Interview: Machine Man
It�s regarded as the most powerful job in the Party, but new NSW ALP general secretary Mark Arbib wants to build a bridge with the union movement.

Unions: Testing Times
Unions are not opposed to drug and alcohol testing, but they do want to see real safety issues addressed, writes Phil Doyle.

Bad Boss: Freespirit Haunts Internet
FreeSpirit forked out a motza for a whiz bang internet presence then disappeared right off the radar � once it was nominated as our Bad Boss for May.

Unions: Badge of Honour
Surry Hills is home to one of the world�s finest displays of union badges thanks to Bill "The Bear" Pirie and a supporting cast headed by Joe Strummer, Mark Knopfler, George Benson, Annie Lennox and other seriously big noises.

National Focus: Noel's World
Shrill bosses bleat over minimum wage rise, union spinmeisters congregate in Melbourne and Tassie�s nurses take the baton from their mob in Victoria reports Noel Hester in this national round up.

Economics: Safe Refuge
A humanitarian approach to refugees and an economically rational one?? I�d like to see that. Frank Stilwell did, when he went to Young in NSW to look into the impact of the Afghan refugees on temporary protection visas who came to work for the local abattoir

International: Global Abuse
Amnesty International have joined the chorus against the violation of trade union rights in the former Soviet republic of Belarus.

History: The Honeypot
To the Honeypot come those individuals anxious to get their hands on instant wealth. So it was in the early days of Broken Hill, wrties Grace Hawes in this homage to the mining town.

Review: Death And The Barbarians
This new take on coming of age films focuses on the coming of death and the dignity and maturity it can inspire among those touched by it - though not always easily in the overcrowded Canadian public health system, writes Tara de Boehmler.

Poetry: Who Wants to be a Millionaire?
Resident Bard David Peetz uncovers some of the unfolding mysteries of talk back radio.


 Big Bribe Misses Battlers

 West in Great Leap Backwards

 Cheques in the Mail

 Bullets Foul Childcare

 Thanks Bob - Lawyers Tuck In

 Watchdog Barks for Workers

 Budget Brushes Elderly Blueprint

 John Sutton�s Fine Idea

 Teachers Unified in Out(r)age

 Qantas Hits Panic Button

 Lights Out At MCG

 Richs to Rags Warning

 Activists What�s On!


The Soapbox
Rethinking Left and Right Part 1
Dr David McKnight, from the University of Technology, Sydney presents a new frame for looking at the competing ideas within Social Democracy.

The Soapbox
Rethinking Left and Right Part 2
David McKnight concludes the paper he presented to the �Rethinking Social Democracy� conference, in London, April 15-17, 2004.

Out On A Limb
Phil Doyle becomes the first Australian journalist to state that the Olympics will be called off.

The Westie Wing
In the latest episode, Ian West explores what Disraeli called "Lies, damn lies and statistics".

Message from America
Searing snapshots from a landscape of uncertainty have plunged the Bush Administration into deeper crisis, writes WorkingForChange's Bill Berkowitz.

About Workers Online
Latest Issue
Print Latest Issue
Previous Issues
Advanced Search

other LaborNET sites

Labor Council of NSW
Vic Trades Hall Council
IT Workers Alliance
Unions on LaborNET
Evatt Foundation

Labor for Refugees



Motherhood Statements

There is a term for political statements that are so bland they have lost their meaning � terms that no one could disagree with, designed to win the support of all people at all times.

They are called 'motherhood' statements: in deference to the one universal virtue that no one would dare attack. Politicians kiss babies because no one can object to babies. And babies come from mothers and mothers are good. Always.

It is the treatment of mothers in the labour market - and the role of fathers for that matter - that has given rise to the most contemporary of motherhood statements - the bipartisan acceptance that 'work and family' is the key issue for contemporary Australians.

The Prime Minister's barbeque stopper is indeed a hot topic - but in the white light of a federal budget and in the run up to a Federal election, it is in danger of losing its original - and indeed - any meaning whatsoever.

The squeeze of work and family has not just appeared on the political landscape - it is the direct consequence of a series of policy decisions over the past decade. At its heart, it is a product of the process of industrial relations deregulation that both political parties pursued through the 80s and 90s.

The Howard Government's approach to Work and Family betrays a mindset that has reduced all public policy to budget line items, an accountants view of the world, where the only things of value are those that can be quantified.

As this week's Federal Budget shows, to the Prime Minister a family friendly policy is a tax cut, a baby bonus and an extra dollar to childcare.

While no one would deny these measures, they speak to a world defined by the fiscal bottom line a position that totally misses the point for most working families.

Yes, we work for the money to live our lives but at the end the day the desire to balance work and family is really about the need to balance the pursuit of salary with the time to meet our family responsibilities.

It is a choice between two competing objectives: money and time. More money helps - but it rarely brings you time. It is a dilemma, which by its very nature cannot be resolved solely on a balance sheet.

At its essence, Work and Family is the challenge of quality of life on the financial bottom line, for both workers and their employers. It is about is building non-economic considerations into the employment relationship. Measures like maternity leave for working mums, the right to return to work part-time, job-sharing are all important. So too are rights like carers leave being built into the employment relationship.

But even where these measures are in place, they can not - in and of themselves - untie the work-family knot.

How, for instance, do we define our working life when we live a life when our working day is defined by the time we turn our mobile phone on in the morning and then turn it off at the end of the day?

How does one quantify the cost of a stressed mother or father on the business's bottom line? How do we gauge how someone whose life is in balance performs better? What is the cost of divorce on productivity? Of depression? Of suicide?

For the Prime Minister and his ilk it's all about preaching the virtues of 'flexibility', a nice little euphemism for deregulation. To Mr. Howard it is the greatest thing for workers since sliced bread.

It is true that "flexible hours" work in some settings but they don't work in jobs that are location specific - teaching, nursing, retail (where most women work) likewise working from home is not an option for many workers, particularly those engaged to deliver specific services face to face.

"Flexible" is a word used a lot in this debate but what most workers want is predictability and more say over their hours and rosters. That's why, despite employer bleating, there is broad community support for the Labor Council's Secure Employment Test Case.

The Test Case is such a challenge to employers - including, sadly, the State Labor Government, because it recognises that the solutions to the work/family imbalance lie in reversing labour market deregulation and actually putting in universal obligations that all employers must comply with.

Far from requiring Motherhood Statements, this issue requires tough, considered intervention in the labour market. And you'll never find that in a Peter Costello budget.

Peter Lewis



*   View entire issue - print all of the articles!

*   Issue 220 contents

email workers to a friend printer-friendly version latest breaking news from labornet

Search All Issues | Latest Issue | Previous Issues | Print Latest Issue

© 1999-2002 Workers Online
Workers Online is a resource for the Labour movement
provided by the Labor Council of NSW
Last Modified: 15 Nov 2005

Powered by APT Solutions
Labor Council of NSW Workers Online