The Official Organ of LaborNET
click here to view the latest edition of Workers Online
The Official Organ of LaborNET
Free home delivery
November 2006   

Interview: Common Ground
Nature Conservation Council director Cate Faehrmann on the fight against global warming and how unions and greens can learn from each other.

Industrial: A Low Act
The Low Paid. The Fair Pay Commission knows who pays them. We can do something about it as they will not.

Unions: The Number of the Least
Forget 666 - 457 is looming as the scariest number for Aussie workers and their families, Jim Marr writes.

Politics: The Smoking Gun
Hayek's henchman, Raplph Harris, goes to free market heaven, writes Evan Jones

Economics: Microcredit, Compulsory Superannuation and Inequality
They are supposed to ensure the wealth of well-being of individuals. Whats wrong with that? asks Neale Towart

Environment: Low Voltage
Nuclear Power and Prime Ministerial pronouncements are seriously short of a few volts, wrties Neal Towart

History: The Art of Social Justice
Tom Martin was a terrific cartoonist and part of a great tradition in labour movement history and culture, swrties Neale Towart.

Review: Work�s Unhealthy Appetite
It pays the bills � usually � but going to work should come with a warning, wrties Jackie Woods.

Culture: A Forgotten Poet
There is little information on the public record about the radical working class poet Ernest Antony, writes Rowan Cahill.


The Soapbox
Robbo Goes Green
John Robertson's speech to the Walk Against Warming

The Westie Wing
Ian West takes a look at a former public institution and its contribution to NSW.


From Green House to Glass House
History tells us that towards the end of most reigns of power the regime stops listening to the people, stops talking to them and reverts to crushes dissent. Events this week suggest this is where the Howard Government is now.


 Godfrey Hirst Carpets Workers

 Lies, Damned Lies and the Shirkin' Gherkin

 Guests Share Backpay Bonanza

 Win, Win for Filipinos

 Honey, They Shrunk Our Pay

 No Sex Thanks, We're Asian

 Green Jobs to Beat Climate Change

 They're Going Out The Door

 Medibank Staff Go Under Knife

 Thompson Slams Door on Delo

 Merchant Bankers Pull Entitlements Stroke

 Green the New Black

 Councils Fight Off Shoring

 Acitivists Notebook

About Workers Online
Latest Issue
Print Latest Issue
Previous Issues
Advanced Search

other LaborNET sites

Labor Council of NSW
Vic Trades Hall Council
IT Workers Alliance
Unions on LaborNET
Evatt Foundation

Labor for Refugees



A Low Act

By Neale Towart

The Low Paid. The Fair Pay Commission knows who pays them. We can do something about it as they will not.

The beloved Low Pay Commission (sorry - Fair Pay Commission) who have just given the low paid a raise of less than the CPI thus dropping the pay further did actually have research on hand to identify the sectors and employers who do pay below $15.00 per hour. So why not live up to their name and target the sectors and employers that pay their workers poorly? Particularly as the low pay these workers get still includes some overtime and penalty rates that WorkChoices aims to get rid of as we all become enterprise workers?

The research has been conducted for the Fair Pay Commission by the impeccably credentialed Melbourne Institute of Applied Economic and Social Research (MIAESR) and the Australian Centre for Research on Employment and Work (ACREW).

The researchers used different definitions of low pay with the Melbourne Institute deeply analysing statistics collected by the Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) and first published in 2004. They defined low paid as under $12.00 per hour (which equated with the federal minimum wage in 2004 of $11.80 per hour). ACREW conducted its own pilot survey and study of 1303 employers and looked at workers earning between $12 and $16 per hour.

Casuals, Low Pay and Penalty Rates

It will be no surprise to workers and unions in the industry that the low paying employers were those who relied on casuals and the main industry areas were retailing, property and business services, restaurants, accommodation AND construction (a fact that bodes in for the industry as the regulations and laws that fetter the role of the union will make it even harder for employees to get a fair deal). For the Institute survey these sectors covered 75% of the low paid. They also found that those who used casuals were most likely to pay less than $12.00 per hour.

These loadings are under attack and the pay rise just handed down, combined with the removal of loadings, will act to ensure that these sectors maintain these low rates. The LHMU CleanStart campaign shows that the major union in this sector is aware and is finding ways to act for these workers, but they know that support will not come from any institutions that are supposedly designed to support such workers.

The ACREW study used a different definition, but also went directly to employers in the sector and attempted to gauge the regional nature of low pay. The employers had at least 50% of workers earning between $12 and $16 per hour. Interestingly manufacturing employers were a larger industry sector based on official categories than retailing. This is most worrying for manufacturing unions, already under immense pressure with so much work moving offshore and lowers skilled jobs particularly facing casualisation and more shiftwork to deal with competition, and penalty rates again being targeted with a push for more AWAs.

The agricultural sector was the highest showing a regional concentration of low pay with impoverishment of the country areas part of the wage structure in Australia, at a time when we have a government supposedly representing regional Australians. This is far higher than ABS data would indicate. But note also that the survey did not look in detail at the sectors below $12 although they do report that over 10% of their respondents reported employing adults at less than $12 per hour

The ACREW study found that labourers and related workers; elementary clerical, sales and service workers; and intermediate clerical, sales and service workers were the types of workers who were in the low paid category.

Regional differences were shown in the study with Tasmania having the highest percentage of employers paying between $12-$16 per hour followed by Victoria. Employer size wasn't a major factor determining employment of the low paid. Employers were also mostly in city areas which is of course where most employment is so that research needs refinement to understand percentages per area population who suffer low pay ad the impact that has on regional development


88% of employers were private sector employers showing that the strength of collectivity in the public sector has maintained a fairer wage structure. With the federal government committed to getting AWAs for its employers, and attempting to enforce them on universities for example, this percentage will balance out unless we get rid of the government, as collective action has maintained decent pay.

Collectivity Equals Equality

The direct result of undermining this collectivity has been shown by the governments own Office of the Employment Advocate, by the ADAM surveys conducted by the Centre for Workplace Research (previously ACIRRT) and now by these studies commissioned by the Fair Pay Commission as a increased spread of pay and increased inequality within workplaces as well as across workplaces and regions. A fair and just Australia has been clearly poorly served by the federal government and the institutions it has created or muzzled. The new boy on the block, the Fair Pay Commission had this research at hand to make a decent decision, but it chose to make a political decision that looks nice, but upon scratching the surface, the pay rise is revealed as a further attack on wage justice that cements inequality.

The reports are on the Fair Pay Commission site:


email workers to a friend printer-friendly version latest breaking news from labornet

Search All Issues | Latest Issue | Previous Issues | Print Latest Issue

© 1999-2002 Workers Online
Workers Online is a resource for the Labour movement
provided by the Labor Council of NSW
Last Modified: 03 Nov 2006

Powered by APT Solutions
Labor Council of NSW Workers Online