The Official Organ of LaborNET
click here to view the latest edition of Workers Online
The Official Organ of LaborNET
Free home delivery
December 2005   

Interview: The Binds That Tie
Dr Don Edgar has demolished the Prime Minister's credentials as a family man.

Unions: Worth Cycling For
Pedal power joined the Your Rights At Work campaign on a 350km journey to take a message to Canberra’s politicians, wrties Phil Doyle.

Industrial: The Elephant in the Corner
Jim Marr takes a look at what the government has secreted away in the WorkChoices package, revealing what is really at stake - and what can be done about it.

Legal: A Law Unto Themselves
In this extract from the Evatt Foundation's 'State of the States' Jeff Shaw & Monika Ciolek look at the constitutional issues rasied by WorkChoices.

Politics: Ethically Lonely
At a forum in the Australian Stock Exchange sponsored by big end of town solicitors, you would expect at least one person to be in favour of John Howard’s industrial relations laws, wrties Rachael Osman-Chin.

History: Women, Unions, Banners and Parades
Trade union banners reveal more about union history than their male designers and makers intended, writes Neale Towart.

Women: Relaxed and Comfortable?
Suzanne Hammond from WEL argues there are many hidden nasties in WorkChoices for working women.

International: The Last Social Democrat
A trade union leader's victory marks beginning of class politics in Israel, wrties Eric Lee

Review: The Corpse Bride
Come to a world where decay, loss and broken dreams are everywhere - and it's not the Federal Senate.

Culture: Tony Moore Holds His Own
In his new book, Tony Moore argues that today's generation of political leaders has much to learn from Bazza McKenzie.


The Soapbox
Whitefellas - You Just Can’t Trust ‘Em.
Racial stereotyping is a bad business. That said, Graham Ring has discovered a segment of society that drinks too much, behaves unreliably and can’t seem to adapt to change. Sadly, the conclusion is inescapable…

The Locker Room
Phil Doyle slices one into the car park.

The Westie Wing
Ian West makes a midnight dash to Workers Online, slides his State political report under the door, then heads back to the Macquarie Street Chamber of Horrors…


A Free Vote
This week’s charade of the Senate amending the Howard Government’s workplace laws raises fundamental questions about the sort of democracy Australia has become.


 Read His Lips: WorkChoices Too Much

 Joyce A Christmas Goose

 Workers Leave Boss in Tool Shed

 Costello Chokes On Asbestos Compo

 Telstra Hangs Up on Former Staff

 Bank Check on Bras

 Bill of Work Rights on Agenda

 Funny Film - Scary Message

 Sign Of the Times

 Unions Chip In for Lauren

 Company Raids Own Ship

 Activist's What's On!

 Million Mum March
 Pension Pinching
 John Bares All
 Radicalising Yoof
 Tom A World Away
About Workers Online
Latest Issue
Print Latest Issue
Previous Issues
Advanced Search

other LaborNET sites

Labor Council of NSW
Vic Trades Hall Council
IT Workers Alliance
Unions on LaborNET
Evatt Foundation

Labor for Refugees



The Elephant in the Corner

Jim Marr takes a look at what the government has secreted away in the WorkChoices package, revealing what is really at stake - and what can be done about it.

You've seen the ads, attended the rallies, heard the warnings - WorkChoices is a dog - bad for working families; giving bosses unprecedented power; stripping away penalty rates and annual leave; driving down the minimum wage; and allowing Aussies to be sacked for no good reason.

It's all true. But there is another dimension to all this - the elephant the government has kept hidden in the corner. That's the way WorkChoices attacks trade unions and undermines our right to work together for a better life. WorkChoices is 700 pages of legalese and every section contains measures to sideline unions, push people onto individual contracts and to punish those who stand together.

Why? Because big business knows unions stand between it and complete control; and their man, the Prime Minister, is aware that without unions, his political opponents will be weaker. It is this unholy alliance that sees unions up against their biggest challenge in 100 years.

Attacking Membership

The federal government says the right to join a union will be "protected by law" but the practise will be very different. WorkChoices sets out to cut the links between working Australians and their unions.

Right of Entry to workplaces will be severely limited. Irrespective of who you elect, the AIRC will decide who is a "fit and proper person" to visit your job. With a Right of Entry permit, union officials must give the employer 24 hours written notice of their intention to visit. If they wish to examine reported "breaches" they must alert the employer, in writing, to the breach they intend to investigate, including the names of anyone affected.

While on site, officials must use a room dictated by the employer and they must follow employer instructions on how to get to and from that room. No union official may enter any site where everyone is employed on an AWA, even if they are all union members. Nor is a union official allowed into premises where employees are non-members.

A unionist breaching any of these provisions, or wrongly claiming Right of Entry, is liable to a $6600 fine and can be stripped of his/her Right of Entry. Unions can be fined $33,000 for every breach.

Stamping on Bargaining

Workchoices goes out of its way to stack the bargaining deck in the favour of employers. By giving notice, they can even terminate negotiated agreements and force employees back to five minimum standards.

The new minimum standards, for all Australian workers, are:

- Basic pay rates, built on the minimum adult wage of $12.75 an hour. There are no guaranteed minimums for "juniors" or the "disabled".

- Four weeks annual leave, with two weeks able to be cashed out

- A 38-hour working week, which can be averaged out over a full year

- Up to one year of unpaid parental leave

- Up to 10 days paid personal (sick or carer's) leave a year.

That's it folks, any contract that meets those conditions is legitimate. There are no provisions for overtime, public holidays or dozens of other entitlements we have won over the years.

If workers want to negotiate collectively and the boss doesn't, there is no provision for conciliation or arbitration to resolve the matter. This has led to Boeing workers at Williamtown, out of Newcastle, striking for months and the Prime Minister standing up in Parliament to back the "right" of the American arms manufacturer to reject collective bargaining.

There is no provision in WorkChoices for "good faith" bargaining. On the contrary, it encourages employers to use AWAs to undermine negotiated arrangements from the day they are signed.

Extraordinarily, employers at new operations, "greenfields" sites, can write their own contracts. True, they can negotiate with themselves, force resulting "agreements" on employees, and keep them in place for five years.

Grinding Down Negotiations

One of the reasons Workchoices is so complicated is because its authors have set out to predict every avenue working people might use to improve their lives, then tried to shut it off. This section of Workchoices blows two of the government's biggest lies out of the water.

Apologists for the changes claim they will get "third parties" out of Aussie workplaces, and that this federal government "trusts" employers and employees to do the right thing. Workchoices trusts nobody and green-lights third-party intervention at every step of the collective agreement making process.

It sets out a list of "prohibited" matters that it will be "unlawful" to agree on, even if both parties want to. Union members can be jailed for even asking for them. Basically, anything that assists union organisation, or recognises its right to be involved in workplace matters, is "prohibited". It is unlawful, in negotiations, to ask for paid delegate training; union involvement in dispute resolution procedures; union access to the workplace, union picnic days, etc.

Key protections for wages and conditions are also "prohibited". These include "pattern bargaining", and restrictions on labour hire or the use of AWAs. Pattern bargaining is government-speak for equal pay at different sites. Under Workchoices it will be "unlawful" for employees at two sites, producing the same materials in the same town, to ask for the same wages and conditions.

In case all this fails and third-party intervention is the only way to enforce government's will, the Minister for Workplace Relations has the right to strike down any clause by regulation. He doesn't need to go to Parliament. Once he puts a line through anything that is being, or has been, agreed, it is "prohibited".

Squashing Industrial Action

The right to strike will be "protected by law", according to John Howard. WorkChoices, however, drastically limits the right to take any form of industrial action. It will only be legal during bargaining periods that can be five years apart. And, it can never lawful in support of "prohibited" matters such as equal pay, restrictions on labour hire or anything else the Minister may take offence to, from time to time.

There are savage fines, up to $33,000 for individual unionists, involved in "unprotected" industrial action.

To engage in any form of "protected" action, workers must:

- apply to the AIRC to conduct a "protected action ballot"

- supply the employer with notice of that intention, including when, where and what the action will be

- organise a secret postal ballot

- the ballot will usually be conducted by the Australian Electoral Commission and unions have to pay 20 percent of its costs

- action must commence within 30 days of the result being declared

- action cannot begin until the employer is given three days notice in writing

- employers, on the other hand, may lockout their workforces, or individuals, without notice

In the event of any "protected" action being effective, Courts, the AIRC or the Minister of Workplace Relations can call it off. The Minister can stop industrial action, even before it starts, on a range of grounds, including that it would "adversely affect the employer".

The AIRC can order "cooling off" periods and can suspend or terminate bargaining periods.Third parties can apply to have 'protected' action terminated and can also claim unlimited damages against workers and their unions. Courts can order injunctions against "protected" action.

Taming the Beast

If that all sounds grim, the campaign to date shows that when the heat is on union members will pull together. To stare down this attack, we need to continue to be smart and disciplined. We will have to understand how the laws work, and decide where and when they can be challenged.

Know your rights - as we have said, it will be harder to take industrial action, but that doesn't mean we don't stand up for our rights and do what is possible within the existing laws.

Stay United - Solidarity will be more important than ever. We can't afford to stand back and workmates, or their unions, to be victimised. Unions are building a network to support workers under attack; when a fight is on, you will be emailed or sms-ed and ask to help. To join up go to

Be strong - these laws are repressive and union officials and rank and file members will face fines and even jail for going about their business. This should not stop us making a stand for what is right

Name and Shame - where employers attack workers under these laws, we need to punish them as consumer; stay informed and use your dollars as a political tool.

Toss Them Out - this is a radical political attack that requires a political response. Our immediate challenge is to toss out every Coalition Member and Senator who supports it and to elect replacements, from whatever Party, who still believe in a Fair Go.


email workers to a friend printer-friendly version latest breaking news from labornet

Search All Issues | Latest Issue | Previous Issues | Print Latest Issue

© 1999-2002 Workers Online
Workers Online is a resource for the Labour movement
provided by the Labor Council of NSW
Last Modified: 04 Dec 2005

Powered by APT Solutions
Labor Council of NSW Workers Online