Workers Online
Workers Online
Workers Online
  Issue No 35 Official Organ of LaborNet 15 October 1999  

 --

 --

 --

Trades Hall

Superman on Choice of Fund

By Mark Lennon - Labour Council executive officer

Since coming to power in 1996 the Coalition Government has had a policy of choice of superannuation fund for employees. At present most employees have their superannuation contributions paid into the fund nominated in their relevant award.

 
 

Superman - Mark Lennon

Their first attempt to implement this policy in 1997 did not receive the support of the cross benches in the Senate and as a consequence the legislation was withdrawn.

Recently the Government has sought to reintroduce the legislation and at the present time is negotiating with the Democrats on the issue.

At the outset it should be made clear that choice of fund is not something new. In NSW for instance, there has been a provision in the Industrial Relations Act allowing an employee to choose a fund other than those designated by their award since 1991. However under this provision the employee elects to make a choice rather than being forced to do so as under the Federal Governments proposal.

More prevalent than choice of fund however has been investment choice within a fund. This involves funds offering members choice of investment strategies which have different risk return profiles. Generally funds offering this type of service will have three or four choices ranging from a high growth strategy to a more conservative capital secure.

In its original form the Federal Governments proposal would have seen employers having to offer either an unlimited choice of funds or a limited choice of four funds. The limited offer had to include the employers fund, the relevant industry fund, a public offer fund and a retirement savings account. Both the unlimited and limited offers had to include a default fund should the employee not elect to make their own choice.

The major concern about the proposal is whether employees will be able to make an informed choice. The likelihood is that members will be bombarded by the retail sector offering a smorgasbord of funds. The risk being that members will make a choice not fully understanding the implications for their retirement plans. This could have implications for the broader community because if the problem becomes widespread and individuals have made insufficient provision for their retirement it could undermine the national retirement incomes policy.

The experience in the United Kingdom with choice serves as a warning. In the mid 80s employees in the UK were given the opportunity to opt out of their company schemes and move to personal pension plans. Many employees took up this option without understanding the consequences. They lost their employer contributions and other benefits and often incurred higher administration costs. Many individuals are now taking action against the providers of the plans for providing misleading advice.

From the union movements perspective clearly there is a belief that industry funds have and will continue to deliver for members. Good returns, low administration costs and an increasing level of services, including investment choice, means that industry funds are the best value for members and therefore make the value of choice questionable.

The Federal Governments proposal is based more on ideological grounds rather than sound policy. I hope the Democrats see it that way as well.


------

*   Got a question? Ask Superman!

*   View entire issue - print all of the articles!

*   Issue 35 contents

In this issue
Features
*  Interview: Strategic Responses
NSW Police Association president Mark Burgess has worked in the coal mines and the waterfront - now he�s the public face of NSW police
*
*  Republic: Negative Campaigning
If the Republic fails, one of the main complaints which should be leveled against the ARM is its refusal to play dirty.
*
*  Unions: Interpreter smooths the way for Kosovar Refugees
�The people really appreciate what Australia has done for them but they still want to go home," said Ariana Biba, a HREA member who has been worked recently as an interpreter assisting newly arrived refugees from Kosovo.
*
*  Education: Count Yorga's Evil Plot
NTEU president Carolyn Allport looks at Kemp's brazen attack on univestities and warns the battle is not won yet.
*
*  Safety: Death in the Snowy
Beyond the engineering achievements of the Snowy Mountains Scheme, there is the tragic story of those workers killed or seriously injured in the construction of the project.
*
*  International: Why Is the WTO So Anti-Labour?
Driving the cost of labour down appears to be the main priority of the World Trade Organisation
*
*  History: The Importance of Tradition
Historical documents bring us into closer contact with the past and its concerns as this 1945 extract from the NSW Nurses Association journal, The Lamp, shows.
*
*  Review: McLibel - The Mice That Roared
This documentary is the classic tale of the little guys against the system, a battle for the right to dissent.
*
*  Satire: Government Privatises Numbers
Prime Minister John Howard released a new policy on numerals yesterday, to bring them in in line with the Liberal Party's plan to privatise �Pretty much everything before we lose office.�
*

News
»  Telstra Workers Turn Reith on his Head
*
»  Revenge of the Working Sick
*
»  McPickets To Hit Centennial Park
*
»  AFL-CIO Computer Deal Keeps Union in Control
*
»  Four Pillars Behind Westpac Cuts
*
»  Labor MPs Asked to Stand Up and Be Counted
*
»  Reith�s Second Wave Smokescreen
*
»  Reith to Legalise Gay and Lesbian Discrimination
*
»  Denham or Lace - Libs to Ravage Public Sector
*
»  The Big Australian Swiftie - $19 Mill Entitlements at Risk
*
»  Real Sweatshops: Ice Cubes To Cool Down
*
»  Xanana Endorses APHEDA
*
»  Tales from the Gender Battlefield
*
»  It�s Time! Republic Goes Funky
*
»  STOP PRESS: Combet Elected ACTU Secretary Unopposed
*

Columns
»  Guest Report
*
»  Sport
*
»  Trades Hall
*
»  Piers Watch
*

Letters to the editor
»  The Very Broad Picture
*
»  Second Wave - Are We Playing To Win
*
»  Don't Let Howard Take The Human Out Of Human Rights
*
»  Tax Ideas Not in the Hunt
*
»  Desperately Seeking Trevor Melksham
*

What you can do

Notice Board
- Check out the latest events

Latest Issue

View entire latest issue
- print all of the articles!

Previous Issues

Subject index

Search all issues

Enter keyword(s):
  


Workers Online - 2nd place Labourstart website of the year


BossWatch


Wobbly Radio



[ Home ][ Notice Board ][ Search ][ Previous Issues ][ Latest Issue ]

© 1999-2000 Labor Council of NSW

LaborNET is a resource for the labour movement provided by the Labor Council of NSW

URL: http://workers.labor.net.au/35/c_tradeshall_choice.html
Last Modified: 15 Nov 2005

[ Privacy Statement | Disclaimer | Credits ]

LaborNET is proudly created, designed and programmed by Social Change Online for the Labor Council of NSW

 *LaborNET*

 Labor Council of NSW

[Workers Online]

[Social Change Online]