The Official Organ of LaborNET
click here to view the latest edition of Workers Online
The Official Organ of LaborNET
Free home delivery
Issue No. 195 12 September 2003  

Coalition of the Swilling
As the world stopped to mark the second anniversary of the September 11 attacks and its horrendous human toll, attempts at writing new rules for global trade were hitting their own immovable object


Interview: Crowded Lives
Labor frontbencher Lindsay Tanner talks us through his new book on the importance of relationships and why politics is letting the people down.

Activists: Life With Brian
Work by men like Brian Fitzpatrick is exposing new Australians to old truths. Jim Marr reports

Industrial: National Focus
A showdown looms in Cancun, Qantas gets bolshie, casual and lazy in its response to aviation challenges, and long festering disputes fester on in Victoria and Tasmania reports Noel Hester in this national wrap.

Unions: If These Walls Could Talk
Trades Hall is preparing for a major facelift but first, Jim Marr reports, it must bid farewell to the colourful bunch who have populated its dusty corridors in recent years.

Economics: Beating the Bastards
Frank Stilwell looks at some of the proposals for building a fairer finance sector.

Media: Three Corners
So its come to this. Four Corners, one of the world's longest running television programs is now under pressure from an ABC Executive that is less cultural visionary than feral abacus.

History: The Brisbane Line
Percy Spender was Menzies' foreign minister, but, Neale Towart asks, was he also prepared to serve as Prime Minister in a Japanese controlled Australia?

Trade: The Dumping Problem
Oxfam-CAA helps set the scene for this month's World Trade Organisation in Cancun.

Review: Frankie's Way
In The Night We Called It A Day Frank Sinatra learns 'sorry' Down Under is a loaded word and refusal to say it when due will lose fans in important places, writes Tara de Boehmler.


 Teachers Attack National Stitch-Up

 Safety Off The Rails

 Lion King Delivers for Kids

 Five Grand Extra for Unionists

 Telstra Gets Curry for Take Aways

 WTO Trips on Cancun Hurdle

 Workers Kicking Goals

 Dial NRMA for Stuff-Up

 This Is Your Operator Freaking

 Millionaire Takes Candy from Carers

 Working Women Get New Voice

 Community Burns Rubber Giant

 Grass Roots Campaign Beats Bush

 Unions-Council Strike ‘Clean Hands’ Partnership

 Call For Campaign To Save Bush Trains

 Activists Notebook


The Soapbox
Staking Our Territory
ACTU secretary Greg Combet argued for a fairer Australia in his keynote address to last month's ACTU Congress.

The Locker Room
Seasonally Agisted
Spring is a season when a person’s thoughts turn to…horse racing. Phil Doyle reports on the fate of nags and folk heroes.

Beyond the Block
We are wild about the people who live in The Block but not too interested in those who are on the streets outside, writes Michael Rafferty.

The Westie Wing
Workers friend Ian West MLC, reports form the Bearpit about a project to raise awareness about trade unionism amongst young people.

The Awkward Squad
Paul Smith meets one of the new generation of British union leaders who is taking the ball up to the Blair spin team.

 Life Wasn’t Meant To Be Frankie
About Workers Online
Latest Issue
Print Latest Issue
Previous Issues
Advanced Search

other LaborNET sites

Labor Council of NSW
Vic Trades Hall Council
IT Workers Alliance
Unions on LaborNET
Evatt Foundation

Labor for Refugees



WTO Trips on Cancun Hurdle

The first two days of the World Trade Organisation’s 5th Ministerial meeting in Cancun, Mexico, have underlined deep conflicts in the global economy, and the prospects for the WTO are becoming dimmer.

The democratic values espoused by the WTO, and by the USA and Europe, are being twisted beyond recognition by the rich minority, reports Workers Online’s man on the ground, Peter Murphy.

That should bring some grim satisfaction to the many people's movements and non-government organisations that have been campaigning against the neo-liberal trade agenda for the last 20 years.

The Australian government's position as the 'champion' of free trade in agricultural products has been marginalised by the emergence of the Group of 21 developing countries, who have proposed a program for sharp reform of agricultural trading policies in the rich countries and more moderate and supportive reforms for developing countries.

While Australia's extreme reform proposals have had no success for over a decade, the G21 has introduced a new dynamic into the WTO that holds out hope of some fair trade measures emerging for agriculture. While publicly cheering on the G21, Australia's delegation is privately predicting that it will soon split. This is clearly the preference of the US and the Europeans. Already reports from the Indian delegation are that US President George Bush has been telephoning individual heads of government from the G21.

Opening day protests and violence

The opening day protests both inside and outside the Convention Centre at Cancun have so far been proven accurate - the WTO is unfair, undemocratic, obsolete and anti-small farmers. The self-sacrifice of former Korean farm leader Lee Kyang-hae at the top of the barricade at the opening protest was met with sadness but also incomprehension by WTO Director-General Supachai Pritchpakdi.

This protest marched through down-town Cancun toward the Zona Hoteleria, with rank on rank of Mexican, other Latin American, US, European, African, Korean, and Filipino farmers and indigenous people expressing the call of the global farmer organisation Via Campesina, for the WTO to remove agriculture from its agenda. When it hit the barricades, the marchers broke through, with 200 Korean farmers in the front line. The momentum was broken by a rock barrage by provocateurs against the huge police and paramilitary force behind the barricades. There were shocking scenes of violence and then the self-sacrifice protest by Mr Lee.

Back at the opening ceremony, the Our World Is Not For Sale network mounted a silent then noisy protest against WTO officials. As a counter-point, the written statement by UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan, and the opening speech by Mexican President Vincente Fox criticised the global trading system and the rich countries and challenged them to hear the voices of the poor, especially small farmers.

Since then protestors have challenged the terms of the August 30 WTO agreement on medicines for poor countries, the forcing of GM corn on Mexico, the huge US cotton subsidies that hurt African cotton growers, and to recognize Mr Lee's self-sacrifice death at the farmers' protest.

Rocks of power politics

September 11 is the first day of intense negotiations, and already the optimism of the WTO leaders and of the Group of 21 has hit the rocks of power politics and self-interest.

While the WTO immediately responded to the Group of 21 request of its proposal for agricultural reform to be given equal status to that of the Chairperson's draft, the European Union is adamantly opposing this view as a 'procedural mess'. The EU has now redefined the Doha commitment which states 'with a view to elimination of export subsidies' for agricultural products, to mean 'no elimination'. The WTO officials now say that 'informal meetings' are the way to get results - that is code for the now notorious 'Green Room' process of meetings by the riches countries, to which the developing countries have strongly objected.

The US failed to heed the call for help from the African cotton growers.

A group of 17 developing countries held a media conference to declare that there is no 'explicit consensus' to launch negotiations on the four 'Singapore issues' - investment, competition policy, government procurement, and trade facilitation - to indicate to the Negotiating Group that it is pointless to pursue this goal any further at Cancun. The 17 want these issues to be referred back to trade ambassadors based at the WTO Geneva office for further clarification.

Meanwhile the EU is adamant that these negotiations must be launched now. These issues are highly controversial, and really amount to a return of the notorious Multilateral Agreement on Investment of 1998 - a charter of rights for transnational corporations elevated above the rights of national governments.

Business response

Australia's Business Council has joined a Joint Business Charter of eleven countries launched at Cancun. The Charter calls of the Cancun meeting to move forward on agriculture and industrial trade liberalization, to start the 'Singapore issues' talks without prejudice on the eventual outcome, to make progress on special and differential treatment for developing and least developed countries, and to renew commitment for more liberalisation in trade in services. The charter cuts across the North - South divide, and expresses the views of globalising capital.

The Wash-Up

Intense pressure will be placed on developing countries tonight and tomorrow to force an agreement that will boost global business confidence, and allow some kind of progress on agriculture, industrial and services trade.

However, this time the developing countries are more informed and united than ever before, and are challenging the established power of the US, Europe, Japan and Canada in the WTO. In turn, this is a real threat to the neo-liberal hegemony of the big transnational corporations from these countries.

The US and EU capacity to offer direct trade deals, and aid, and of the International Monetary Fund to deny credit, will be used to try to kick-start the flagging neo-liberal momentum. Big capital is seriously concerned at the low levels of growth in world trade of the last two years.

Whatever happens, the grassroots campaigns against the global corporate agenda are getting stronger and more capable of impacting governments. If an agreement is openly coerced at Cancun, it will seriously damage what legitimacy remains for the corporate claim that it is best place to order the global economy, and therefore global social relations and environmental conditions.


*   View entire issue - print all of the articles!

*   Issue 195 contents

email workers to a friend printer-friendly version latest breaking news from labornet

Search All Issues | Latest Issue | Previous Issues | Print Latest Issue

© 1999-2002 Workers Online
Workers Online is a resource for the Labour movement
provided by the Labor Council of NSW
Last Modified: 15 Nov 2005

Powered by APT Solutions
Labor Council of NSW Workers Online