The Official Organ of LaborNET
click here to view the latest edition of Workers Online
The Official Organ of LaborNET
Free home delivery
Issue No. 183 20 June 2003  

A Beautiful Set of Numbers?
In the coming week the NSW Government will hand down the first budget of its third term. Few things are certain in politics, but rest assured the budget will be characterised as ‘tough and responsible’.


History: Nest of Traitors
Rowan Cahill uncovers a ripping yarn that could redefine the way we look at Australian involvement in World War II.

Interview: A Nation of Hope
Former PM Bob Hawke bemoans the demise of industrial relations but takes heart from the prospect of peace in the Middle East

Unions: National Focus
Noel Hester reports on a soap star rebellion, Howard’s plans to renuclearise South Australia, more historical atrocities in the north, the redundancy test case plus more in the monthly national wrap.

Safety: The Shocking Truth
It’s every power worker’s worst nightmare – and it happened to Adrian Ware. In a flash of voltage, his life changed forever, as Jim Marr reports.

Tribute: A Comrade Departed
From Prime Ministers to wharfies, the labour movement paid tribute to Tas Bull this week. Jim Marr was among them.

History: Working Bees
Neale Towart looks at a group of workers who got sacked so their boss could keep making the Bomb.

Education: The Big Picture
The NTEU’s Dr Mike Donaldson and Tony Brown join all the dots in the current debate around higher eduction.

International: Static Labour
Ray Marcelo argues there’s another side to the recent furore over Telstra’s use of cheap Indian IT contractors.

Economics: Budget And Fudge It
Frank Stilwell argues that Peter Costello’s latest budget plumbs fiscal policy to new depths.

Technology: Google and Campaigning
Labourstart’s Eric Lee argues the latest weapon for campaigning could be the humble search engine.

Review: Secretary With A Difference
Looking for a new job can be hard enough, without having to worry about sadomasochistic bosses and the threat of being spanked for forgetting to cross your ‘t’s, says Tara de Boehmler.

Poetry: The Minimale
The Labor Party leadership is in the news again, inspiring our resident bard David Peetz to song

Satire: Howard Calls for Senate to be Replaced by Clap-O-Meter
John Howard released a controversial policy statement today, arguing that the Senate be abolished in favour of a device measuring noise from the gallery of the House of Representatives.


 Task Force Sleeps Through Killing

 Go To Gaol – Do Not Collect $500,000

 Green Pollie in Picket Blue

 D-Day for Media Diversity

 Putting Steel into Government’s Spine

 Fortnight in Killing Fields Anyone?

 Underpaid Worker Fights Deportation

 Truckies Deliver Death Watch

 Job Cuts Caught in Spill Cycle

 Mum Wins Family Friendly Hours

 Allianz Plans Bite the Dust

 Aussies Back Zimbabwe’s Gaoled Strikers

 Boral Faces Stadium Stoush

 Drought Claims More Jobs

 Bridge Chaos Looms

 Activist Notebook


It’s Our Party
Long time union watcher Nicholas Way looks at the changing dynamics between the industrial and political wings of the labour movement.

The Soapbox
Grass Roots
In his Maiden Speech, new MP Tony Burke argues that the ALP’s union links are nothing to be ashamed of.

Opinion Forming Down Under
Evan Jones condemns the mainstream’s media coverage of the War on Iraq and the damage it is doing to our national psyche.

The Locker Room
Location, Re-Location!
It’s all fun and games until someone loses a club, writes Phil Doyle

 Questions for Cuba
 Is Beazley's Popularity a Winner?
 Rank Marchers
About Workers Online
Latest Issue
Print Latest Issue
Previous Issues
Advanced Search

other LaborNET sites

Labor Council of NSW
Vic Trades Hall Council
IT Workers Alliance
Unions on LaborNET
Evatt Foundation

Labor for Refugees



A Beautiful Set of Numbers?

In the coming week the NSW Government will hand down the first budget of its third term. Few things are certain in politics, but rest assured the budget will be characterised as ‘tough and responsible’.

Treasurer Michael Egan and his team carry the mantle of debt-activists in the finest tradition of the deficit hawkes who captured the ALP in the era that bears the same name.

There is no doubt that Labor governments need to be good economic managers, better than the Tories, and the Carr-Egan Administration has been amongst the most successful in living memory.

Buoyed by the Sydney 2000 Olympics, the tax windfall from the property boom and a conservative attitude to public spending, Treasurer Egan has a track record the envy of any Tory Treasurer.

The Bart Simpson of state politics has a hard-earned record of delivering 'beautiful sets of numbers' that earn the approval of mainstream economic commentators year in, year out. More strength to him, we say.

Our question is whether delivering surplus budgets is in and of itself sufficient to claim to have delivered a 'Labor budget' - which is the Egan mantra this time of year.

Reducing deficits is important; money spent servicing a debt is money that can't be spent in the here and now.

But as any home-owner will tell you, sometimes you need to borrow to be able to afford shelter and transport, while maintaining the sort of income required to feed the family, pay the school fees and meet the doctors bills.

In 1997 Egan thought he had found his Shangri-la when he was convinced that selling off the power industry would wipe out the budget. As experience in other states has shown, privatisation would have seriously compromised the state's electricity supply, robbing future generations of secure, affordable electricity.

The French keep telling him he could get a motza for water infrastructure as well, yet to date he has resisted that temptation. And let's not forget the state's rail tracks - the Commonwealth currently wants to seize them for an $850 million investment, a necessary first step to a national sell-off of another state asset.

What these policy dilemmas show is that not even a government as fiscally conservative as Carr's believes the budget bottom line is everything.

There was a time of course, where the size of the budget deficit was an important economic lever - to drive up economic activity by injecting funds in publicly useful projects. Think Snowy Hydro, think Harbour Bridge, think Olympics. Sometimes you spend your way back to economic life.

So Egan's budget fetish is one way of managing the state's finances, but it is not necessarily the only Labor model.

Part of Egan's conservatism is borne out of the financial debacles associated with a string of Labor Governments in other states in the early 90s.

As an opposition leader at the time, Carr would have resolved firmly never to allow a disaster of the proportions of the Victorian Cain Government Pyramid Collapse to afflict NSW Labor. The question is, have Carr and Egan over-learned this lesson and taken Labor too far in the opposite direction?

There have been moments of inspiration. Land tax for properties valued at over a million dollars was an inspired piece of Laborism that targeted tax on the manifest beneficiaries of the economic boom.

But all too often the Egan budgets have been exercises in perspiration over inspiration; with the boffins steering the ship of state and the raw figures being the beginning, middle and end of the story.

So what would a Labor budget really look like?

It would show an increased investment in the public services where they are needed, both in physical and human capital.

It would be investing in projects that will improve the quality of life for citizens - an integrated public transport, a well-resourced health system, teachers who received decent recognition for the fundamental contribution they make to our society.

It would ensure that public funds are invested in public sector careers, rather than filling in the gaps with massive use of casuals and labour hire.

It would adequately fund TAFE, encourage apprentices and divert government contracts to good corporate citizens.

And it would build in indicators to ensure the money that is being spent is being fairly distributed amongst regions, with the main indicator being need.

The problem with budgets is that they are raw set of numbers that in their crudest form deliver a rating based on a bottom line: the profit and loss statement.

The state is not a corporation and we are not shareholders and we should view the Michael Egan's ninth budget as something more than a maths exam.

The role of Treasurer is to be more than a security guard on the state coffers who says no to every request for money. It involves arguing the case for increased revenue, even taxation, in the interests of building a stronger community.

That's the altogether tougher test that Egan faces if he wants to be regarded as a great Labor Treasurer.

Peter Lewis



*   View entire issue - print all of the articles!

*   Issue 183 contents

email workers to a friend printer-friendly version latest breaking news from labornet

Search All Issues | Latest Issue | Previous Issues | Print Latest Issue

© 1999-2002 Workers Online
Workers Online is a resource for the Labour movement
provided by the Labor Council of NSW
Last Modified: 15 Nov 2005

Powered by APT Solutions
Labor Council of NSW Workers Online