|
Issue No. 152 | 13 September 2002 |
The Legacy of 11/9
Interview: Still Flying International: President Gas Politics: Australia: A Rogue State? History: Levelling September Unions: Welfare Max Bad Boss: Welcome to Telstra! Health: Fat Albert: The Grim Reaper Poetry: A Man From the East And A Man From The West Review: The Sum Of All Fears
�Robbed Generation� Seeks Stolen Wages One Year On: Ansett Crash Still Hurts Cole Exposed By Immigration Scam Car Workers on Howard Hit List Mystery Windfall for Hilton Workers Track Grab Ignores Lessons of Glenbrook Bosses Say No Living Wage For NSW Childcarers Pastry Workers Tell Boss To Get Puffed Victorian Zookeepers Down Buckets Pride and Safety for Workers Out!
Legends The Locker Room Bosswatch Week in Review Awards Activists
The CFMEU Race Debate #2 Keeping it Clean Sue the Leaders?
Labor Council of NSW |
Tool Shed Schoolyard Bully
**************** Long-term Workers Online readers would know we have been long-term Piers-Watchers - spending a full year analysing the fat man's work before being beaten into submission by his banal bigotry. But even we had never seen him stoop to the depths of turning the words of a 16-year-old school girl against the entire Muslim community. But there he was this week, as the world was trying to make sense of the horrendous events of 12 months ago - events that claimed thousands of innocent lives in the US and Afghanastan - doing what he's always done best: playing for the cheap political point. The catalyst for the attack was a Letter to the Editor sent by 16-year-old Amira Sbbet from Miller, who described herself as a "Lebanese Muslim". It is not a particularly sophisticated letter, but it is one girl's reaction to the growing community backlash against her community. As Muslim social worker Paula Aboud told a recent NSW Fabians forum - "it's feral out there at the moment". There is a level of community abuse that has been orchestrated by the political and media elites. This girl tried to make sense of it all, defending the beliefs of her family from the current 'panics' of S11, the gang rape trials and the order to stone a Nigerian women for committing adultery. To this girl, the issues had melded into one narrative - that she and her family were not worthy of respect. In her instinctive, but clumsy defence, she opened herself up to attack from Piers. Remember this is a 16-year-old girl writing a Letter to the Editor - not a community leader speaking on behalf of a constituency. But on the morning after the anniversary of September 11, it was she that Piers chose to pick on. Of course, we at Workers Online do not support this girls' views, but on a day we remember the dire costs of misunderstanding the Other, we could have expected a commentator in one of the nation's leading newspapers to display a little more sensitivity. Piers' shame is that he looks at a Muslim and sees a suicide bomber. At a time when the world is crying for peace, Piers' reflex is attack. On our reading Amira is no terrorist, just a schoolgirl who has been hurt by bigotry trying to stand up for a set of beliefs which she feels are under attack. Piers' subtext is the same sorry dog-whistle that has characterised much of the media commentary in recent times: Muslims are the problem, they have no place here, they are bad news. It is a mean, grubby and dangerous doctrine. It's been a consistent theme from Piers who has been donning the fatigues in recent times, laying into Labor's erudite foreign affairs spokesman Kevin Rudd. Rudd's drawn fire from Piers' for publicly arguing that the rule of international law - as opposed to Bush Law - should apply when considering whether to bomb the bejesus out of Baghdad. For this outrageous stance, Piers has dubbed Rudd 'Pixie' and thrown buckets of muck in his general direction - drawing Rudd into a reply this week. Unlike Piers, Rudd did a bit of research on Piers recent work and came up with some interesting - though hardly surprising facts. Analysing 150 Piers articles written in the last 12 months (tough work - I know how it feels) they came up with the following score card: on 88 occasions he directly attacked Labor for its various crimes against humanity. On 31 occasions he endorsed Liberal policy. As for positive comments on Labor: zero, zilch, blotto. In 12 months, this so-called journalists could not find a single thing to agree on Labor about. In these uncertain times, it is good to know there are some constants. One if Pier's one-eyed prosecution of the Howard Agenda by seeding the cracks through which he can drive his trademark wedge. For Piers peace, love and understanding are for wimps - and if a 16-year-old schoolgirl gets in the way of the war juggernaut, their is only one thing to do: run her over.
View our Gallery of Tools Nominate a Tool!
|
Search All Issues | Latest Issue | Previous Issues | Print Latest Issue |
© 1999-2002 Workers Online |
|