The Official Organ of LaborNET
click here to view the latest edition of Workers Online
The Official Organ of LaborNET
Free home delivery
Issue No. 148 16 August 2002  
E D I T O R I A L

Peak Performance
Leaders of the NSW trade union movement gathered this week to consider the role of their peak council in an increasingly deregulated labour market.

F E A T U R E S

Interview: Labor Law
NSW Attorney General Bob Debus expands on how he's bought a Labor agenda to the justice system

Unions: Critical Conditions
Jim Marr looks at one man's story to expose the workers compensdation rorts that are rife in the building industry

Bad Boss: Shifting The Load
Barminco, the biggest mine operator in Tasmania, has put its name forward for a Tony after being labeled the �boss from hell�.

History: Peeking Out
As unions push for workplace privacy, Neale Towart argues that its not just employers who might be peeking.

Safety: Flying High
Blaming the individual worker has always been at the heart of calls for random drug and alcohol testing, Neal Towart reports.

Corporate: Salaries High, Performance Low
As part of Labor Council's inquiry into executive pay, Bosswatch's Chris Owen has compiled this overview.

International: War on the US Wharves
Thousands of US dockworkers held rallies this week up and down America�s West Coast as well as in Hawaii, as the Bush Administration threatened to break one of America�s most powerful unions by using troopers as strike breakers.

Review: And the Signs Said...
Philip Farruggio argues the new horror flick 'The Signs' has a subtext that should resonate with working families.

Poetry: Tony Don't Preach
Melbourne car park attendant and LHMU delegate Tony Duras rewrote the Madonna and Kelly Osbourne hit Papa Don�t Preach.

Satire: Latham Dumps Rodney Rude as Speech Writer
ALP front-bencher, Mark Latham has fired speech writer Rodney Rude after calling the Prime Minister an 'arse-licker'.

N E W S

 Qantas Dressed Down Over Uniform Backflip

 Virgin Threatens Delegate Over Net Use

 Email Protection Hits Firewall

 Yarra Gets Rowdy Welcome Home

 Cole Snubs Injured Worker

 Victorian System Needs Reform: AIRC

 First NEST Payout to Workers

 Qld Public Sector Battle Heats Up

 Community Workers Eye Canberra Show Down

 Lift Techs Face Redundancy Lock Out

 Council Workers Win Picnic Day Fight

 School Support Staff Demand Recongition

 Black Chicks Talk At Refuge Fundraiser

 Colombian Left MP Applying For Asylum

 Activist Notebook

C O L U M N S

Politics
Colour By Numbers
Labor council secretary John Robertson argues that the 60-40 debate ignores the real changes necessary in the ALP.

The Soapbox
Peas in a Pod
ACTU President Sharan Burrow gives her take on the new fetish for Public-Private Partnerships

The Locker Room
Go Dogs Go
As a student of form, Phil Doyle discovers that the Greyhounds are coming up in class and are all the better for recent racing.

Bosswatch
Rayland And Other Adventures
More evidence emerges in the HIH Royal Commission of the joys of life at the Top End of Town.

Human Rights
Tampa Day
Monday 26th August is no celebration, but the first anniversary of a National Shame should be recognised, writes Amanda Tattersall.

L E T T E R S
 Miranda's Not Fair on Outworkers
 Another Capitalist Party?
 Justice For All?
 Kill the Photos!
 Right Wing Lackies
WHAT YOU CAN DO
About Workers Online
Latest Issue
Print Latest Issue
Previous Issues
Advanced Search

other LaborNET sites

Labor Council of NSW
Vic Trades Hall Council
IT Workers Alliance
Bosswatch
Unions on LaborNET
Evatt Foundation


Labor for Refugees

BossWatch



Unions

Critical Conditions


Jim Marr looks at one man's story to expose the workers compensdation rorts that are rife in the building industry

*********

Thirty eight-year-old Chris Gillespie is a construction industry veteran. He feels more like a football being mauled over by a heavyweight scrum of lawyers, doctors and shonky employers.

Storm Gloria, at 11 months, is a veteran of emergency helicopter rides and life-saving surgery. She is also, her father says, the principal reason he hasn't toured Sydney construction sites looking to take the law into his own hands.

The pair have a bond but, at 10kg, she has just hit the maximum weight doctors say her father can lift.

It's been that way since Gillespie wrecked his back, bulging two discs, dessicating another and getting a "convex" spine while working for employers who didn't pay workers comp levies or top-up insurance.

The upshot has been no compo and no treatment as steel fixing companies deny liability; insurance companies shove him from pillar to post and compensation lawyers PK Simpson - motto: Homer doesn't work here but PK does - leave him reaching for another Duff.

He doesn't drive any more because the car's out of rego. Basically, he's living off his girlfriend, Storm's mother, has been since he had to give up the lease on his own flat a year ago.

"I'm fucked up," he admits. "I went through a divorce a few years back but this is worse. My moods are all over the place, it's a constant battle to stay on an even keel.

"Honestly, if it wasn't for my daughter I don't know what would happen.

"It's just so depressing to go from being a working man to somebody who sponges off his girlfriend."

And a working man he certainly was.

After cutting his teeth as a builder's labourer in Sydney on projects such as the Commonwealth Bank in Martin Place, and a stint with the BWIU, he headed for Queensland.

He's been a formworker, concreter, paver, labourer, patcher and ganger, driven forklifts and all-terrain vehicles on construction sites across the northern state. Most memorably, he lasted nearly six months reclaiming mangroves for an extension to the Cairns International Airport runway.

"We were knee-deep in mud and mangroves being bitten by fire ants, leeches and bugs," he recalls. "Me and another bloke who had been there a while used to take bets on how long newcomers would last, sometimes it was 20 minutes, sometimes until smoko, if they were real fit we would give them a couple of days.

"We were usually on the money."

He worked a few years for the Engine Drivers Union, organising in south west Queensland.

Cunamulla has become famous/infamous since his day.

"It was a good town, mate," he says. "When it got a bit quiet there you could always drive 80km down the highway for a beer at the Eulo Queen."

Gillespie would travel the west with his old cattle dog for company. One of his proudest achievements was selling the benefits of union membership to a whole group of wheat farmers, moonlighting as council workers, in the heart of the conservative Darling Downs.

Between construction jobs he kept food on the table with stints in tourism and hospitality, including tours of duty as a kitchen hand, beverage manager and restaurant supervisor on Hamilton Island, and running an abseiling enterprise in the spectacular Kuranda Rain Forest.

But that's all ancient history.

In 1997, one exam short of his safety officer's ticket, Gillespie returned to NSW to spend a few days with his seriously ill father at Narrabri. He got work, as a leading hand rebuilding the town's main street, and stayed a few months.

Back in Sydney, he was talked into trying his hand at steel fixing by mates at the Kingswood Hotel, near Penrith. It was a decision that would change his life.

Steel fixers, by and large, are a law unto themselves. Work comes and goes and workers often move from one employer to another, and back again, sometimes in the same week.

For their part, the employers, by and large, are what CFMEU secretary Andrew Ferguson calls shonks.

Typically, they understate employees to rip off the public on tax, payroll tax, workers comp, top-up insurance and other liabilities. If anyone puts their weights up they usually change the company's name and carry on.

From late 1997, Gillespie found himself plying the trade for C and H, Foxy's Reinforcing, Rum Steelfixing, Multifix and Ronnie's Reo.

C and H, he thinks, were legit.

There were small jobs and some substantial ones too, including redevelopments at the Rosehill and Randwick racecourses and plenty of residential work.

With hindsight, Gillespie concedes, most were cutting corners.

"They rip the system off blind and it's not just one or two of them, it would be 90 percent of the companies steel fixing in NSW," he says.

On one site he worked alongside illegal immigrants. Wage slips were a rarity.

He came to grief on a Saturday, laying steel in a creek at the National Rail Centre development at Challora.

"It was just one of those things," he says. "I had an armful of big steel rods and was laying them into position.. I ran out of room with my feet and moved one foot backwards, and I heard - pop, pop, pop - and my back was gone."

The next work day he reported to the first aid shed and told the boss he wanted to see a doctor.

"He just said - fuck off, you're not putting a back claim on my compo. You don't need to see a doctor, take it easy for a couple of days and you'll be alright.

"He talked me out of it because, I guess, I didn't want to have a bad back. When you've spent your life in the building industry you don't want to have anything that will stop you getting work when it comes along."

He did a couple of weeks with another of his regular employers and the back got neither worse nor better.

On that job, workers didn't get paid one week because the employer had gone to Melbourne for the races and done his dough.Most of his workmates, it transpired, were being paid cash in hand and when the Westfield union delegate found out he had the company kicked off the site.

"When the boss gets back he calls a meeting with the boys in the Strathfield Hotel. He knows its me who told the union delegate about the wage records and he calls me a useless #@$$ #^$#.

"He was furious and I didn't know the other blokes on that job very well. I could see myself walking around the edge of the building and wondering if I was going over the side.

"It wasn't something I needed at the time, so I quit."

Gillespie went back to the Randwick Racecourse job, got transferred to a big residential development in North Parramatta where constant stair work aggravated his back.

Back at Randwick, the pain became unbearable. He went to the first aid shed and filled in the forms. The employer got another worker to drop him at Central Station in the company ute.

On the express to Penrith, the employer rang on his mobile. The message was similar to that he had received from the boss when the injury first occurred - don't, under any circumstances, go claiming workers comp.

It was June, 2000, the final day of his working life.

His doctor sent him for a CAT scan and identified three bulging discs. It was here that the real frustration sent in.

"I rang Foxy and told him they said I had a lifetime injury and I would have to make a claim. He just swore at me and hung up," Gillespie recalls.

None of the three employers would accept any responsibility. The middle one, the one without wage slips, went so far as to deny he every employed him, something backed up by the lack of documentation.

The companies' respective insurers, QBE, GIO and Employers Mutual got in on the act. Between them they have sent him to at least 15 different doctors, orthapaedic specialists included, in an apparent bid to quibble with the diagnosis, since confirmed by MRI.

At one point, QBE appeared to have accepted the claim. It backpaid him and started paying weekly entitlements. Then, in March this year, they declined responsibility, cutting off support.

"They'd sent me to a Doctor Bornstein in Balmain. Apparently, his report said my injuries were more applicable to one of the other employers than the one they represented.

"They cut off the money and the treatment."

He hadn't been financial with the union so put his hope in "compensation

specialists" PK Simpson. After months they got him to court but arrived without the necessary paperwork and the compensation court has put him back to the bottom of its list.

Since March, Gillespie has been getting Centrelink payments as a single disability pensioner and no treatment for his back.

He tried to visit an orthapaedic surgeon in Penrith but he wouldn't bulk bill and the $150 consultation fee was out of the question.

"I have been in super since year dot, since we started marching down George St, demanding it," he says, "but none of these guys made contributions.

"There's no insurance, no compo, no nothing."

"I can't believe it, there are days when I make a wrong move and I can't do a thing, not even walk and you know what I do? Usually, I take it out on my girlfriend."

Eventually, he swallowed his pride and, out of desperation, rang the CFMEU. They've agreed to take up his case so there is some light on the horizon.

Has the experience left him with any advice for others in the steel fixing game around NSW?

Sure, but it's not worth wasting breath on - fill in the forms, make sure you get wage slips and that you're entitlements are being paid.

"Everyone knows that," he says but, in steel fixing, "you try to enforce it and you don't work"

Okay, more personally, what do you want?

That's easier.

First and foremost, he would like to see the three employers he has had since doing his back locked up in jail. Then, when they are released, the two from New Zealand deported.

He would like some money, preferably the workers compensation he is entitled to.

Mostly, though, he wants treatment for his back.

"I want this whole bloody merry-go-round of lawyers, doctors, shonky bosses and insurance companies to stop and let me off," he said.

"Then, I want to get fixed up so I can work again. I want my life back, I want to be able to look after my girlfriend and our daughter.

"I want to be a man again."


------

*   View entire issue - print all of the articles!

*   Issue 148 contents



email workers to a friend printer-friendly version latest breaking news from labornet


Search All Issues | Latest Issue | Previous Issues | Print Latest Issue

© 1999-2002 Workers Online
Workers Online is a resource for the Labour movement
provided by the Labor Council of NSW
URL: http://workers.labor.net.au/148/b_tradeunion_chris.html
Last Modified: 15 Nov 2005

Powered by APT Solutions
Labor Council of NSW Workers Online
LaborNET