The Official Organ of LaborNET
click here to view the latest edition of Workers Online
The Official Organ of LaborNET
Free home delivery
Issue No. 136 17 May 2002  
E D I T O R I A L

Modern Labour
Unveiling his 'modern Labor' pitch in the Budget in Reply, Opposition leader Simon Crean seemed very 1950s � when 'modern' was good in itself, like spray-cans, zippers and uncomfortable furniture.

F E A T U R E S

Interview: Licking the Wounds
Elder statesman Neville Wran expands on his review into Labor's performance at the last federal election.

Industrial: The Accidental Tourist
Standing on a picket line, just metres from the sleaziest part of Kings Cross, was not what Cheshire chemist David Lui had in mind when he was saving for his trip of a lifetime.

Unions: Stars And Stripes
Fly the flag, beat the war drum and screw the old, the sick and the poor � Peter Costello�s budget aims to emulate the worst aspects of American politics argues Noel Hester.

International: The Un-Promised Land
Andrew Casey lifts the lid on a little-known campaign to establish a Jewish homeland in the Kimberleys.

History: Mate Against Mate
Neale Towart trawls the records to recount some of the more acrimonious ALP State Conference debates.

Politics: Reith's Gong
Peter Reith's medal from the HR Nicholls Society overlooks a number of lamentable aspects about his character as Stuart Mackenzie reports.

Poetry: You've Got a Friend
A friend is someone who protects you, but in an interesting twist the Federal budget has redefined the notion of 'protection' by adding the word 'from'.

Review: War on Terror: Now Showing
Arnold Schwarznegger's latest flick Collateral Damage is spooky for many reasons, writes Tara de Boehmler.

Satire: Burmese Regime Makes Genuine Commitment To Pretence Of Change
The government of Myanmar (Burma) released democratic opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi today after a year and a half of house arrest.

N E W S

 Solidarity In The Post To East Timor

 Joy Wins For All Workers

 Workers Call Abbott On Democracy Bluff

 Wran Tells MPs: Talk to Unions

 Family First on Conference Agenda

 Cole Commission Declares Paper War

 Yarra Workers Thank Australia

 Budget Attacks Retirement Incomes

 PSA Challenges Carr�s Secrecy Shield

 Election Talk Aint Cheap

 Hotel Bosses Back Down On Pay

 Welfare Staff Strike Out At Harrassment

 Della Ups DIR Inspectorate

 Fake Notes Expose Government as Tax Cheat

 Labor Faces Acid Test on Asylum Seekers

 New Project Encourages Cultural Exchanges

 Bush�s Western Saharan War And Oil Deal

 Activists Notebook

C O L U M N S

The Soapbox
Border Solidarity
The Australian Workers Union's Bill Shorten explains why he drew a line in the cement in support of the CSL Yarra crew

The Locker Room
The Dangerous Life Of A Hot Dog Seller
Phil Doyle ruminates on the virtues of processed meats in the world of elite sports.

Bosswatch
The Bottom Line
Peter Costello wasn't the only one flaunting a budget deficit this week, as Rupert Murdoch announced the largest corporate write-down on record.

Postcard
East Timor Appeals For Help
At midnight on Sunday 19 May, the UN mandate in East Timor comes to an end and East Timor becomes a new independent nation.

Week in Review
The Spin Cycle
Budget week brings that much spin you half expect to see Shane Warne wheeled out as a spokesman on health, economics, or whatever else the combatants are blabbing about. Jim Marr lifts the covers.

L E T T E R S
 Gangsta Rap
 More May Day Hate Mail
 What Women Want
 Chucking a Wobbly
 Is Caustic Costello the Despot of Despair?
 East Timor: Independent Or Mendicant?
WHAT YOU CAN DO
About Workers Online
Latest Issue
Print Latest Issue
Previous Issues
Advanced Search

other LaborNET sites

Labor Council of NSW
Vic Trades Hall Council
IT Workers Alliance
Bosswatch
Unions on LaborNET
Evatt Foundation


Labor for Refugees

BossWatch



Review

War on Terror: Now Showing


Arnold Schwarznegger's latest flick Collateral Damage is spooky for many reasons, writes Tara de Boehmler.
 

*************

Why this film spooked me. One: it was shot before the US terrorist attacks last September, yet contains many parallels with these events. Two: Arnie inadvertently challenges the belief American actions played no role in the World Trade tragedy. Three: it harks back to a time where American individualism was God, shortly before the whole world was forced to pledge whether it stood with the US or against them.

Taking on board the parallels within the plot, one could be forgiven for thinking this time capsule of a movie had been produced in direct response to President Bush's chief political advisor Karl Rove's call for the film industry to contribute to the "war on terrorism".

In the wake of the attacks, his suggested methods by which this could be achieved involved the inclusion of themes such as: recognising that the US campaign in Afghanistan is a war against terrorism, not Islam; publicising government's call for community service; US troops and their families need to be supported; the September 11 attacks were global attacks requiring a global response; the US campaign is a "war on evil"; the government and film industry have the responsibility to reassure children of their safety.

But no. Because Collateral Damage was released prior to all these suggestions it simply represents a time when crooks were just crooks, terrorists were crooks, and one US citizen could and - in guaranteeing a ball-tearing yarn probably should - single-handedly conquer all of the above.

The only area where the film truly meets Rove's criteria is that it leaves no doubt children throughout the world are very safe. Because, even if the US government fails miserably to protect them, Arnie will dodge bullets and tankers, leap large waterfalls in a single bound and eat steel cap boots to protect the little tykes. And that holds true whether they are American children or children from the very lands and loins of said crooks.

And so the story begins. Arnold Schwartznegger, firefighter, family man and whatever the singular word for folk might be watches aghast as his wife and young son are blown up by a terrorist bomb planted in a popular outdoor caf�. Doubly aghast when both the CIA and the FBI fail to give the case the priority it deserves, Arnie becomes a man on a mission, pledging to catch the crooks and make them pay, while producing as little collateral damage as possible.

This, he explains, is the difference between the right way of doing things and the way terrorists achieve their ends. Terrorists kill innocent people. Arnie looks after the innocents on all sides of the fence. Which is how he comes to literally bump into the wife and child of the very man who blew up his own family.

After having trawled all the way to sunny Columbia in search of the guerillas responsible for the bombing, idly walking through a busy marketplace, when suddenly a fast moving vehicle comes careering straight for a young boy. Arnie instinctively jumps to his rescue, thereby cementing for himself a permanent place in the heart of the hapless kid's mother Selina (played by Francesca Neri). The fact that she is the wife of his family's killer is taken like a grain of salt by Arnie until he is later captured by the crook, aka "the Wolf" (played by Cliff Curtis), and forced to rely on Selina's kindness.

It is during this time that moviegoers are treated to some rare and welcome insights. The Wolf was not always a bad man. Once he and Selina had a little girl but she was killed in an attack led by US soldiers. That was when her once levelheaded husband metamorphosed into the deadly Wolf. Kind of like Arnie, he sought revenge, except he joined the guerillas to exact punishment on those who hurt his family whereas Arnie chose to go it alone.

Selina does not like what the Wolf has become but stands by him out of love and a desire to keep what is left of their young family together. She and her child are still reasonable, despite all that they have lost. So reasonable is Selina that she confides in Arnie that she can no longer stand by and watch her brutal husband kill innocent people. She and her son come back with Arnie to the US as refugees where she reveals her husband's plans for the next terrorist attack and helps track him down.

So maybe there is more to this movie than meets the eye. It appears to at least try to paint the other side of the terrorism picture, encouraging moviegoers to consider what possible atrocities might lead a reasonable person to become a terrorist.

Except it turns out you really can't trust even the family of a crook.

In a dramatic turn of events, Selina reveals she is the Colombian equivalent to Osama Bin Laden. She is the mysterious and elusive mastermind behind all the attacks and she is now orchestrating the next attack, the one Arnie is inadvertently assisting by placing his trust in her. What is more, she is willing to blow up her own son to achieve her wicked ends.

What comes next is the bitter realisation that one has been foiled again by yet another two-bit Hollywood blockbuster with more cash, explosions and special effects than common sense.

If the movie was shot now it might be different. There would probably be more emphasis on American patriotism rather than the plight of the individual. The task of fighting terrorists would not be left in the hands of one man, no matter how indestructible. The references to US attacks on innocent Columbians might also be deleted.

But even if Collateral Damage was shot too soon to represent the US Government's suggested themes, the Australian Government must surely support its current form.

Let's recap: asylum seekers are willing to sacrifice their own children to meet their selfish ends; don't let asylum seekers into your trust, if they do not have direct links, they might even be Osama Bin Laden; and organisations claiming to fight for freedom and liberation are quite likely to have terrorist linkages.

A few months ago I overheard a conversation on a bus where one geezer turned to the other and said "September 11? Oh, I'm kinda over it. Not much has been happening for a while". Is the movie-going public really over it or will Collateral Damage constitute a rollicking box office success.

Rating: Two stars (May there never be a sequel)


------

*   View entire issue - print all of the articles!

*   Issue 136 contents



email workers to a friend latest breaking news from labornet


Search All Issues | Latest Issue | Previous Issues | Print Latest Issue

© 1999-2002 Workers Online
Workers Online is a resource for the Labour movement
provided by the Labor Council of NSW
URL: http://workers.labor.net.au/136/d_review_flicks.html
Last Modified: 15 Nov 2005

Powered by APT Solutions
Labor Council of NSW Workers Online
LaborNET