The Official Organ of LaborNET
click here to view the latest edition of Workers Online
The Official Organ of LaborNET
Free home delivery
Issue No. 134 03 May 2002  
E D I T O R I A L

The Hijacking of May Day
Unionists watching the shambolic and violent affair that was the M1 protest could be forgiven for wondering what has become of the traditional workers' day?

F E A T U R E S

Interview: Youth Group
Federal Labor's youngest frontbencher, Nicola Roxon, on how the ALP can win back the hearts and minds of the young.

History: Back To The Future
As building unions put old animosity aside, Neale Towart looks at the history of the 'demarc' - and the steps taken to avoid them.

Industrial: On the Street
Jim Marr looks at the human cost of Treasurer Peter Costello's refusal to fund a pay rise for community workers.

Unions: The New Deal
Adam Kerslake outlines the importance of the ground-breaking pact between unions in the building and civil construction industries.

Legal: The Police State Road
Rowan Cahill argues that the Howard Government's new anti-terror laws carries echoes of a more sinister past.

Women: What Women Want
When 300 ALP women from around Australia converged on Canberra for the National Labor Women�s Conference they had more than quotas on thier minds, Alison Peters reports.

Politics: Street Party
Paul Howes looks at how May Day was celebrated around the Globe by those involved in trade unions and those who are not.

International: The Costs of War
Ariel Sharon is facing growing pressure from Israeli unions over the conduct of his war on Palestine, reports Andrew Casey.

Review: Songs of Solidarity
It had rock, grunge, pop and rap. The May Day union anthem song contest had everything, including an element of surprise thanks to competition winner Swarmy G.

Satire: Bono Satisfies World Hunger for Preachy Rockstars
U2�s lead singer Bono has launched a daring solo mission to end the world�s hunger for rock stars who use their high profiles to crap on self-righteously about charitable causes.

Poetry: Woomera
Divide and rule, that age old tactic...the lips of defence personnel inexcusably sewn to dehumanise an imaginary threat, the lives of asylum seekers incomprehensively dehumanised so as to defend a threatening image.

N E W S

 Yarra Seamen Take Border Stand

 War on Terror Targets Unions

 Year Zero for Building Unions

 Kinkos Copies Anti-Union Script

 Nike Told to Shoosh on Sweatshops

 Rapper Wins Wobbly Anthem Prize

 Technicians Take Aim At Canon

 Unions Target Labour Hire Bidding War

 Rally Targets Tight-Arse Costello

 Councils To Be Audited On Language Allowance

 Scope For Payback In Privacy Limitations

 Heavyweight Push For Medibank Private To Stay Public

 What About Dad? - TWU

 East Timor MPs Question Timor Gap Plan

 Artists' Union Bans Voice For Peace

 Activist Notebook

C O L U M N S

The Soapbox
Maurie on May Day
PSA supremo Maurie O'Sullivan had them in the palms of his hands when he delivered the traditional May Day Toast.

The Locker Room
Impractical Punting
Most of life is six to five against. That is, unless you know a Packer or a Waterhouse. Phil Doyle expands.

Bosswatch
Show Me The Money!
It may be May Day - but life in the banking industry has never been sweeter - unless you're in the gambling caper.

Week in Review
Two Bob Each Way
The double standards of modern life have left Jim Marr scratching his head.

Tool Shed
Border Insurgent
Deputy Prime Minister John Anderson has blockaded himself into the Tool Shed this week for opening Australia's borders up to flag of convenience ships with Third World crews.

L E T T E R S
 Doctors in the Bush
 M1 Open Letter
 Julian Online
 May Day Debacle
 Mothers Day Musings
 Greetings From Canada
WHAT YOU CAN DO
About Workers Online
Latest Issue
Print Latest Issue
Previous Issues
Advanced Search

other LaborNET sites

Labor Council of NSW
Vic Trades Hall Council
IT Workers Alliance
Bosswatch
Unions on LaborNET
Evatt Foundation


Labor for Refugees

BossWatch



News

East Timor MPs Question Timor Gap Plan


As East Timor approaches its independence on 20 May, Australia is pressurising the East Timorese leadership to ratify the 5 July 2001 Timor Gap Memorandum of Understanding (MoU).

Australia wants the MoU signed, sealed and delivered by or immediately after 20 May. And if that happens, East Timor stands to loose billions of dollars in loyalties from the oil and gas tax revenues in the Timor Sea and thousands of much needed jobs.

However, several members of the elected East Timor's Constitutional Assembly (which will become East Timor's new parliament) now want to delay the signing of the MoU for at least six months--they want a parliamentary committee set up to fully investigate all aspects of the draft agreement. They are mainly from two of the main opposition parties--Partido Democr�tico (PD) with seven members in the assembly and Partido Social Democrata (PSD) with six members in the assembly.

This latest development arose after they heard legal experts advised them at a weekend seminar held in Dili in March that East Timor should own most of the natural gas and oil field in the Timor Sea.

According to Eusebio Guterres, a PD member of the assembly who attended the seminar, the new East Timorese Parliament has to ratify any agreement signed. He believes all members of the assembly must be fully briefed before making that decision.

Eusebio, is a lawyer and former director of the Labour Advocacy Institute of East Timor (LAIFET).

'The MPs cannot make a sound and correct decision that would benefit the people of East Timor, unless they fully understand the issues involved. That is why we need a parliamentary committee to review submissions from the oil companies, lawyers, economists, geologists, engineers, scientists and other consultants,' Eusebio said.

'Parliament must not be used just as a rubber stamp,' he added.

It appears most assembly members have been kept in the dark and have very little understanding or knowledge about the MoU--only a handful of people were involved in the negotiations--most of them foreign UN advisers to Chief Minister Alkatiri and Foreign Minister Horta

The seminar was also told by a leading oil and gas engineer, Geoff McKee, and the former head of US oil company Uncoal, John Imle that it is possible and possibly less expensive to build pipelines from the gas fields of Bayu-Undan and Greater Sunrise to East Timor then to Darwin. These information had been made available to senior members of the United Nations Transitional Authority (UNTAET) and the East Timor Transitional Authority (ETTA) for the past two years.

At stake is $US50.4 billion of potential tax revenue from the three oil and gas fields in the Timor Sea--Bayu-Undan (US$12.4 billion), Greater Sunrise (US$36 billion) and Laminaria/Corralina ($US2 billion). In addition, if the gas were to be piped onshore, it would create an estimated 4,000 jobs and billions of dollars in industrial spin-offs.

The MoU is largely based on the 1989 Timor Gap Treaty with Indonesia. It established a Zone of Co-operation (ZoC) to divide up the oil and gas resources between Australia and Indonesia on a 50:50 split in Zone A of the ZoC. It favours Australia because it uses the continental shelf seabed boundary rather than the medium-line (half way) boundary between the two coastlines.

Bayu-Undan falls inside Zone A. However only 20% of the eastern gas field of Greater Sunrise is inside Zone A--the remaining 80% is in Australia's Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ)--so is the western oil field of Laminaria/Corralina.

In drafting the MoU, the medium line boundary was not applied. And to add to the disadvantage of East Timor, Zone A is retained as the Joint Petroleum Development Area (JPDA). But instead of a 50:50 split, Australia agreed to increase East Timor's share to 90%. This means East Timor is entitled to 90% of Bayu-Undan but only 18% of Greater Sunrise under the 90:10 revenue split, but no revenue from Laminaria/Corralina.

However, if the medium line boundary is applied--the whole of Bayu-Undan would fall inside East Timor's EEZ. And if East Timor than applies the eastern and western lateral boundaries, at least 80% of Greater Sunrise and 100% of Laminaria/Corralina would fall inside East Timor's EEZ.

'We want the maritime boundaries between East Timor and Australia settled by an independent arbitrator. After that is done, we cam discuss the formula for revenue sharing,' Eusebio said.

Eusebio also refutes Foreign Minister Alexander Downer's claim that Australia has been generous to East Timor and he is correct in saying so.

The oil field of Laminaria/Corralina which should belong to East Timor has began production--providing US$300 million in tax revenue for Australia in 2000 and US$350 million in 2001.

As can be seen, for the past two years a total of US$650 million has been siphoned off from East Timor. In other words Australia's generous contribution to East Timor has been paid for by money which rightfully belongs to them. And as the years go by it would be East Timor contributing to Australia's coffer rather then the other way round--where is the generosity!

Eusebio and his colleagues are worried if the MoU is ratified, East Timor might not be able to revisit points of contention at a later date.

Their concerns are shared by three eminent international law specialists--Professor Vaughan Lowe from Oxford University, Christopher Carleton from the UK Marine Hydrographic Office and Australian barrister, Christopher Ward.

In a legal opinion released on 22 April 2002 they stated: 'It is important that East Timor be fully advised prior to entering into any agreement that defines the limits of its rights over the seabed, even a "temporary" or provisional agreement, because any such agreement may materially affect East Timor's long-term entitlement to the resources of the seas and seabed off its coasts.'

The full legal opinion with a detailed map can be found on the website: www.gat.com/Timor_Site.

In helping to draft the MoU, UNTAET has failed in its duty of care. And in turn, Australia has take advantage of East Timor's lack of experience and knowledge.

It must not be forgotten that it was largely due to the UN's and Australia's initial inaction that led to over 75% of East Timor's infrastructure being destroyed in September 1999 by the TNI sponsored militia violence.

Had Ian Martin, the then UNAMET head of mission and the UN taken a tougher stand with Indonesia, and had Foreign Minister Downer and his Department not withheld vital information, the destruction of East Timor might have been avoided. Let's not forget Downer was still talking about 'rouge elements' when Dili began to burn in early September 1999.

Australia and the UN must therefore make amends with East Timor by providing them with the best possible deal.

HT Lee


------

*   View entire issue - print all of the articles!

*   Issue 134 contents



email workers to a friend latest breaking news from labornet


Search All Issues | Latest Issue | Previous Issues | Print Latest Issue

© 1999-2002 Workers Online
Workers Online is a resource for the Labour movement
provided by the Labor Council of NSW
URL: http://workers.labor.net.au/134/news8_ht.html
Last Modified: 15 Nov 2005

Powered by APT Solutions
Labor Council of NSW Workers Online
LaborNET