The Official Organ of LaborNET
click here to view the latest edition of Workers Online
The Official Organ of LaborNET
Free home delivery
Issue No. 124 15 February 2002  

Chickens Come Home
For anyone who believes in karma, the events of the summer show how bad Australia's is right now.


Unions: Winning the Heartland
John Robertson unveils new research on attitudes to refugees and argues it's time for unions to mount their own propaganda war.

Interview: Swan's Song
Federal ALP front-bencher Wayne Swan expands on his ideas for rebuilding the Party in the wake of the Tampa election.

Corporate: Lessons from Enron
Jim Marr looks at the shock-waves the collapse of a US corporate heavy-weight are having around the globe.

Politics: What We Did Last Summer
We look back over a summer when it all went pear-shaped. Some events, at home and abroad, look set to have ongoing ramifications.

History: Solidarity in Song
Mark Gregory looks back on the annals of labour songs and offers some hints for those planning a tilt at the Labor Council's worker anthem comp.

International: A Tale of Two Cities
New York and Port Alegre are poles apart � but they both played host to important conferences on the future of globalisation over the summer.

Poetry: Nobody Told Me
Labour academic David Peetz commits the Prime Minister's current woes to verse.

Review: Labor and the Rings
Tolkien�s epic tale provides a timely reminder that that there are forces of good and evil in the world � and that they are not necessarily where we expect to find them, writes Michael Gadiel.

Satire: Rafter Named Bermudan Of The Year For Tax Purposes
Australian of the Year Pat Rafter was last night also named Bermudan of the Year, in a simple ceremony held in Bermuda's Parliament.


 Unions' Commit to Battle for Hearts

 Carr on Notice - Expectations Up

 Mad Monk Sides With Angels � Briefly

 Maritime Union Acts on Spy Scandal

 May Day Play-Off for Workers' Anthem

 Burmese Links Shroud Winter Olympics

 New Phone Venture One.Tel In Drag

 Two Million Face Rights Downgrade

 Enron Collapse Hits Share-Owner Agenda

 Corrrigan Snaps Up Rail Bargain

 Kinko Clowns With Workers' Rights

 MPs Face Security Checks

 Telstra's Tragic Delays Of Its Own Making

 Burrow Puts Case to World Economic Forum

 Shangri La Protests Hit Melbourne

 Activists Notebook


The Soapbox
Chinks in the Armour
The ACTU's Michael Crosby argues that Mark Latham's attack on the Labor for Refugees movement is the betrayal of Party values.

The Locker Room
Off-side in Korea?
With the World Cup set to kick off in a matter of months, South Korea's treatment of unions is under the microscope.

Week in Review
Cloak and Dagger
In the first of what will be a regular column, we place the week's labour news into a nutshell.

 In Whose Interests?
 'International Labour's Year in Review' - A Re-View
 Belly's Broad-Side
 Collins Gets Cryptic
About Workers Online
Latest Issue
Print Latest Issue
Previous Issues
Advanced Search

other LaborNET sites

Labor Council of NSW
Vic Trades Hall Council
IT Workers Alliance
Unions on LaborNET
Evatt Foundation

Labor for Refugees



A Tale of Two Cities

By Terry Bell *

New York and Port Alegre are poles apart � but they both played host to important conferences on the future of globalisation over the summer.

President Thabo Mbeki


A tale of two cities, heavy with irony and laden with symbolism, was played out over the summer. One of its more interesting features was the attendance of two prominent South Africans.

Their presence at the respective venues summarises quite well the main ideological and policy debates in the globalising world of today. President Thabo Mbeki attended the World Economic Forum (WEF) in New York; while Cosatu president, Willie Madisha, was at the World Social Forum (WSF) in Porto Alegre, Brazil.

New York is, of course, the brash capital of rampant capitalism; Porto Alegre the centre of the rapidly growing movement against "corporate-driven globalisation".

The WEF was founded privately in Davos, Switzerland as a discussion and lobbying forum for the world's top industrialists and financiers. On an annual basis, they wine, dine and woo the leaders of governments around the world.

The WSF was set up two years ago in direct response to the WEF. It draws together a much larger, more diverse and often fractious group of delegates than the WEF and is committed to the idea of an "alternative" to the present world economic order. Although made up of a variety of ideological strains, the WSF tends to be united in condemning the WEF as an "elitist, rich old boys' club". This "Davos club" is seen as arrogant and authoritarian, even dangerous to the future security of the bulk of the world's population.

But for all the often fiery rhetoric, this thrust from Brazil is not so much revolutionary as reformist; a case of Maynard Keynes versus Milton Friedman; of interventionism versus the anarchy of the market.

At Porto Alegre, the names and ideas of Mao, Trotsky, Lenin and Marx may hover on the fringes, but the centre stage will be held by the likes of Noam Chomsky, an incisive analyst and radical reformer. His opposite number in New York will be seen in the likes of the currency speculating billionaire philanthropist, George Soros.

The two highest profile South African representatives to stride these two stages were Mbeki and Madisha. Mbeki was in New York talking investment and the extolling the virtues of South Africa's liberal macro-economic regime. Madisha was in Porto Alegre, extolling the possibility of "another world" and building links with the large and historically militant trade union federation, CUT.

This was particularly easy to do in Porto Alegre, capital of the province of Rio Grande do Sul, since both are governed by the CUT-supported Workers' Party (PT). But there was some apparent common ground between the two gatherings.

Both tended to agree that increasing poverty and the social and political ramifications of this, amount to the biggest problem facing the world today. Both also tended to agree that the world has a surplus of almost every basic necessity. The parting of the ways comes with the ideas for how to deal with this situation.

This is our own macro-economic battle on an international plane; GEAR (growth employment and redistribution) versus the social equity orientation supported by the trade unions.

The arguments about the need for still greater growth and higher productivity in order to encourage a greater trickle down of wealth should once again emanate from the corridors of the WEF. From the WSF should come freshly packaged versions of the need to redistribute existing wealth in order to encourage equitable growth.

At a fundamental level, these points of departure are impossible to reconcile. So for all the recent murmurings of toenadering between government and Cosatu nothing much appears to have changed. Despite the unions being under the whip of recession and economic restructuring, their battle continues, only becoming more clearly international.

Even the South-South "trade butterfly" touted by the department of trade and industry is now in the process of having a mirror trade union structure created. This "butterfly" concept advanced the notion of increased trade and investment between South Africa � the "body" extending northwards into Africa �Asia and South America. Brazil would be key to the "wing" in the west, India and South Korea to the east.

Madisha's talks with CUT were part of a process begun recently, which should see Cosatu working much more closely with the Brazilian unions and with the presently embattled and highly militant unions of South Korea. A "solidarity butterfly" seems in the making. Perhaps it will be another metaphorical butterfly that stings like a bee.


Terry Bell is a Cape Town-based freelance writer, columnist and editor, banned and in exile from South Africa for 27 years. A trade unionist, socialist and former political detainee, has written the syndicated "Inside Labour" column since 1996.

An early editor of Anti-Apartheid News in Britain, keynote speaker at the inaugural conference of the NZ Anti-Apartheid Movement, NZ Peace Squadron activist, founder-principal of the primary division of the Somafco school for SA exiles in Tanzania, and co-ordinator of the international "Friends of Moses Mayekiso" campaign.

Author of the recently published "Unfinished Business - South Africa, apartheid & truth" written in collaboration with leading SA human rights lawyer and former Truth and Reconciliation Commission investigations unit head, Dumisa Ntsebeza.

John Pilger has said of this book: "...a brilliant, important book that should be read by everybody interested in the truth behind the 'truth and reconciliation' hype of the new South Africa...reveals the cover-ups and charades that allowed the shock troops of apartheid to get away with a crime against humanity."

Unfinished Business may be ordered through this e-mail address - belnews@ - by fax (below) or from P. O. Box 373, Muizenberg 7950, South Africa.

Payment may be via transmission to: T. Bell, Nedbank, Salt River, Cape Town; account number 2021 325385 (please fax/e-mail details of such payments) or by crossed cheque to T. Bell.

PS: we are using any income from the book to finance Understanding Our Past, an attempt to uncover as much hidden apartheid history as we can.

-Tel: +27 +21 +788 9699

Fax: +27 +21 +788 9711-


*    More South African news

*   View entire issue - print all of the articles!

*   Issue 124 contents

*   Email this page to a friend

Search All Issues | Latest Issue | Previous Issues | Print Latest Issue

© 1999-2002 Workers Online
Workers Online is a resource for the Labour movement
provided by the Labor Council of NSW
Last Modified: 15 Nov 2005

Powered by APT Solutions
Labor Council of NSW Workers Online